Skip navigation

PLN editor quoted in article re BOP prisoner Tommy Silverstein's long term in solitary confinement

CNN, Jan. 1, 2010.
PLN editor quoted in article re BOP prisoner Tommy Silverstein's long term in solitary confinement - CNN 2010

'Terrible Tommy' spends 27 years in solitary confinement

By Stephanie Chen, CNN

(CNN) -- Tommy Silverstein has been held in solitary confinement for the past 27 years, longer than anyone else in the federal prison system, his lawyers say.

He is locked up at the high-security prison in Florence, Colorado, known as Supermax. The lights are always on. Guards who slip him food through a slot in his cell door usually ignore him. A few times a week, he is permitted to exercise in the recreation room -- alone. Visits with his family and his lawyers are conducted through Plexiglas.

Silverstein's isolation is the result of an unusual no-human-contact order issued by a judge in 1983, after he murdered a guard at the federal prison in Marion, Illinois. Marion was known at the time as the most rigorous confinement in the federal prison system.

Silverstein has referred to his solitary existence as "a slow, constant peeling of the skin."

His attorneys, who are affiliated with the University of Denver, filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Bureau of Prisons in 2007, alleging that the such prison conditions violate the cruel and unusual punishment clause of the Eighth Amendment. The lawsuit, filed in the federal district court of Colorado, is awaiting trial.

At Supermax, Silverstein, 58, practices yoga and meditates in his cell. He might catch an episode of "the Sopranos" or a reality show on the black-and-white TV in his cell. It's his only way to see the outside world.

Recently, he's learned to crochet, and he fills much of his time writing letters.

He has two Web sites being run by advocates and family friends: and

One of the sites includes examples of Silverstein's prison artwork and writing, providing a glimpse into a life of isolation. Blue-toned drawings show hands trapped behind bars. Black-and-white ones starkly show cage-like conditions.

"It's almost more humane to kill someone immediately than it is to intentionally bury a man alive," he wrote in a 2008 letter to a friend.

Psychologists who have studied the effects of solitary confinement find that the lack of social interaction can cause severe anxiety and depression. Some inmates in solitary have committed suicide.

Eyes like a 'wild person'

His sister, Sydney McMurray, came from California to Colorado to visit him a year ago. She said he seemed exhausted, with eyes like a "wild person."

"Relax, Tommy," she told him through the thick Plexiglas. "It's OK."

She hopes Silverstein will someday find peace. She says she draws solace from the legend of Bodhi Dharma, a monk who, according to some accounts, retreated to a cave to meditate alone for nine years.

"They say you come back crazy or come back wise," McMurray says. "Tommy's always been a strong guy, and I think this has made him wiser."

McMurray says she believes her brother has changed, and she knows he has suffered from reading his letters.

CNN attempted to contact Silverstein by mail, but he did not respond. Access to him is limited. To date, only one journalist has interviewed him, in 1988.

The U.S. Bureau of Prisons says "solitary confinement," a term widely used by prison advocacy groups and attorneys, doesn't exist in federal prisons. Instead, authorities call the isolated cells where inmates are housed the SHU: special housing units.

U.S. Bureau of Prisons spokesman Edmond Ross estimates that on any given day, 11,150 of the 200,000 federal inmates are kept in special housing units. The reasons for confinement vary from protecting a witness to disciplinary measures.

In the U.S., the practice dates to the 1820s, when Quakers believed that complete isolation forced prisoners to repent. But in 1890, the Supreme Court ruled that confinement had disastrous mental effects, causing inmates to go insane and become violent.

'Worse than death row'

"At times, it was worse than death row. At least death row had privileges," Robert Hillary King said.

King is one of the Angola 3, a trio of Louisiana inmates who were locked away in solitary confinement in the 1970s. Two of the three men were accused of stabbing a corrections officer.

King, who was never charged with the killing, won his freedom in 2001 after a series of appeals. He had spent 29 years in solitary confinement in the state prison system. The other two members of the Angola 3 are still being held in isolation.

For Silverstein, his adult life behind bars began in 1978. He was a 26-year-old Californian with a heroin addiction when he was handed a 15-year sentence for robberies he committed with his father.

Two years later, Silverstein was convicted of murder for the first time: the slaying of a fellow inmate in a Kansas prison.

He was moved to a maximum-security prison in Marion, Illinois. His murder conviction was overturned while he was there.

At about the same time, he was rumored to be part of the Aryan Brotherhood prison gang and was targeted by other inmates, according to his former attorney Daniel Manville, who now practices in Michigan.

Silverstein was convicted of murdering two Marion inmates.

But it was the highly publicized 1983 murder of prison guard Merle Clutts that led to Silverstein's unusual no-contact order. Silverstein fatally stabbed the 51-year-old.

CNN could not find family members of the two inmates Silverstein killed or any members of Clutts' family. His wife is deceased.

Clutts, who had worked for the federal prison system for 19 years, is remembered fondly by corrections workers and friends in an online memorial page maintained by a nonprofit called Officer Down Memorial Page Inc.

One fellow corrections officer wrote: "You are a hero because you did not give in to inmates or let them intimidate you in any way. You were attacked by some animal who should have gotten the death penalty, but instead still [exists] in our world."

Deeming Silverstein a hazard, authorities transferred him to a federal prison in Atlanta, Georgia, where he was confined in a 6-by-7-foot cell, legal documents show. The living space was cramped for Silverstein, who is more than 6 feet tall. Bright lights lit the cell 24 hours a day, and surveillance cameras scrutinized him.

He became known as Terrible Tommy.

'The Silverstein suite'

In 1987, a group of Cuban inmates rioted and took control of the prison. They freed Silverstein and then traded him back to prison authorities in hopes of lightening their sentences.

Silverstein was then shipped to Leavenworth, Kansas. Once again, prison officials kept him isolated, this time alone in the basement. Authorities nicknamed his cell the Silverstein suite.

Leavenworth's conditions were an upgrade, although legal documents allege that rats infested his cell at one point. The cell space increased to 9 feet by 16 feet, court documents say.

The isolation offered Silverstein a chance to focus on his artwork, a hobby since childhood, his sister says. Art became therapy and his way of communicating his harsh conditions to the outside world.

Silverstein's final move came in 2005 to Supermax, the most secure federal prison in the U.S. He remains there today, along with Unabomber Ted Kaczynski and a long list of other well-known criminals.

Silverstein isn't trying to deny his responsibility for the three prison murders, nor is he trying to get out of prison, his lawyers say. He is remorseful, and two decades of good behavior should allow him to join the general prison population, they say.

The U.S. Bureau of Prisons declined to comment on Silverstein's behavioral history.

In 2008, he was moved to less isolated living conditions. Although he is still alone and still has no contact with other people, his cell is now next to others, says his lawyer, Laura Rovner.

"He's holding up extremely well," said Paul Wright, an editor at Prison Legal News who has corresponded with Silverstein by letters over the past decade. "I think that for 95 percent of the population, they would have gone stark raving mad years and decades ago."